Are Manu and Tony Hall of Fame worthy?


The guys at ESPN are at it once again. This time, they talked about international players that are Hall of Fame bound.

The panel of five believes Manu Ginobili is a surefire Hall of Famer but thinks that Tony Parker isn’t quite there yet.

Here’s their take.

On Manu

David Thorpe, Scouts Inc.: He is, indeed. Manu’s savvy scoring talents worked perfectly within the Spurs’ system, and his passing gifts allowed the Spurs to employ a score-first point guard. Tim Duncan is a top-10 player historically, but Ginobili was a perfect scoring guard to pair with him as well, thanks to excellent shot selection and a huge heart. Few players at that position were better than Manu in his prime, and all who were will be Hall of Famers, too.

Jay Aych, The Painted Area: Absolutely. Manu’s NBA stats and accolades stack up favorably compared to Joe Dumars’. Would Ginobili get into an NBA-only HOF? Probably, but that’s debatable. When you take into consideration his European accomplishments pre-NBA and his success with the Argentine national team, Manu is a lock next to Bill Bradley, the only player to win Olympic gold, Euroleague title and NBA title.

Rob Mahoney, The Two Man Game: Absolutely. What Ginobili’s résumé lacks in longevity, it makes up for it with a string of incredible successes. From 2002-07, Ginobili became an All-Star, posted an average player efficiency rating of 21.1, won three NBA titles, championed Argentina to a gold medal in the Olympic games and led his team to a second-place finish in the FIBA World Championship. Throw that Ginobili did for the “euro step” in the NBA what Allen Iverson did for the crossover, and he certainly qualifies as a basketball luminary.

Jonathan Santiago, Cowbell Kingdom: Ginobili has been a key cog on each of the Spurs’ championship teams of the past decade. And internationally, he led a team that dethroned the United States in the Olympics for the first time since the U.S. started sending professionals.

Jared Wade, 8 Points In 9 Seconds: Yes. He won three NBA titles, an Olympic gold medal, a Euroleague title and an Italian league title. Individually, he has two All-NBA selections, a Sixth Man award, a Euroleague MVP and a few Italian league MVPs. On pure talent, he is no Kobe or Dwyane. He’s not even Drexler or Dumars. But he is so accomplished that he gets the nod.

On Parker

David Thorpe, Scouts Inc.: Yes. It’s not just the rings, either. For years, Parker has literally been one of the top paint scorers in the league. Try these numbers on for size: In the past five seasons, Parker has never made less than 62.7 percent of his rim shots, while current MVP Derrick Rose made 60 percent of his last season, his best showing ever. When a team’s point guard can get to the rim and finish like Parker can, everything else on offense flows so much more easily. Inch for inch and pound for pound, Parker had a stretch as probably the most potent offensive weapon in the NBA.

Jay Aych, The Painted Area: Obviously his NBA career has a lot in common with Ginobili’s, so I’ll say yes. Parker is maybe the best international point guard ever after Steve Nash. He also was a key figure on three NBA title teams and was Finals MVP in 2007. However, he does not have quite the résumé that Manu and Pau have in FIBA play.

Rob Mahoney, The Two Man Game: Maybe. Parker’s career, more than that of any other player included in this space, depends on the years to come. Like Ginobili, Parker is a three-time champion. He also has a trio of All-Star appearances to his name and a handful of highly productive seasons. But Parker has yet to reach the heights that Ginobili once claimed and hasn’t had the same level of international success. Parker may be a Hall of Famer yet, but he’s not quite there.

Jonathan Santiago, Cowbell Kingdom: I’m iffy about Parker because unlike Tim Duncan and Manu Ginobili, he’s never really won as the focal point of a team. Duncan has always been the centerpiece of all the Spurs’ championship teams, and Ginobili, as I said earlier, led Argentina to a gold-medal victory in the Olympics. With that said, he’s probably a Hall of Famer simply by being the most decorated basketball player to emerge from France.

Jared Wade, 8 Points In 9 Seconds: Nope. He is a huge step below both Manu and Pau in talent and can’t come close to matching their decorated international careers. I’m not even sure there is a legitimate case to be made for Parker, unless perhaps you think Chauncey Billups or Horace Grant is a Hall of Famer.

(via ESPN/NBA)

Now lets dig in some numbers.

For his career, Parker is averaging 16.7 points, 5.7 assists and 3.1 rebounds on 49.3 percent shooting from the floor.

Ginobili on the other hand is averaging 15.3 points, 3.9 assists and 4.0 rebounds on 44.9 percent field goal shooting in his nine-year career.

Those are not Kobe or Chris Paul like numbers, but you have to consider the fact that both of them where able to produce and certainly lend a big hand during the Spurs three title runs while playing with one of the greatest big man of All Time in Duncan.

Manu gets the unanimous nod because besides his NBA success, he was able to lead Argentina to an Olympic gold medal and an MVP at that.

Parker might need more work, but it should be remembered that he was the Finals MVP in 2007 when the Spurs swept the Cleveland Cavaliers and is arguably the best international player that came out from France. That should speak volumes.

What are your thoughts? Are Manu and Tony Hall of Fame worthy? Tell us what you think.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Are Manu and Tony Hall of Fame worthy?

  1. Without a doubt Manu Ginobili and Tony Parker will be Hall Famers when the time comes. Of course Duncan too, without a question. Go Spurs Go!

  2. Pau Gasol = Manu Ginobili? And Parker is below Gasol? These ESPN analysts must be Lakers fans. Gasol is soft!

    Manu is one of the fiercest competitor to play the game and Parker isn’t afraid to get hit and one of the best guards at scoring in the paint, he is anchoring the Spurs offense for quite a while now.

    So YES! Manu and Parker are Hall of Famers together with Tim Duncan.

  3. Obviously, I like Tony Parker a lot. He has helped the Spurs to win three NBA titles, not Nash, Chris Paul, Deron Williams, Derrick Rose or even Deron Williams can say that.

    Parker is the most successful NBA point guard today.

    Manu equally deserves it because he always plays his hearts out for the Spurs and for Argentina.

  4. With my bias aside, I believe Manu should definitely be a Hall of Famer along side Tim Duncan. Parker in my opinion is almost there, if he plays very well for the Spurs next season (whenever it starts) and help France reach new heights in international competition that will seal the deal.

    Thanks for all the comments and reads and the for the continued support here at Spurs World. I appreciate it!

  5. This are the kind of post we can expect because of a lockout. FWIW, Ginobili, Parker and Duncan should all be Hall of famers when they are done with their NBA careers.

  6. When their career’s are finally said and done all three will be HOF. Their numbers and jerseys will be retire and hanging from the rafters. However; I believe that TP might follow a different path to getting there by having to prove more and it might just finally come threw another team at the end. But there is no doubt they’ll be there in time.

  7. Given that it’s the writers who adjudicate this all who knows ? But I feel that ….. give the duo two more years at a minimum to pad their respective stats and perhaps win another title then we could very well see them as nominees for the Hall of Fame . It’s obvious as of now that Nowitzki will be a shoo-in for the accolade .

    But consider this also the criteria is five years after their retirement a player can be nominated . So in that respect would you say that Robert Horry ought to be a worthy nominee for the Hall of Fame ? Simply look at the number of titles won and his contributions to the teams where he played . ‘nough said !

    tophatal …….

  8. Pingback: Duncan, Ginobili listed among NBA players who may be ready to retire soon « Spurs World

Speak your Mind...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s